| R | 2-2 | R35 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| R | 2-2 | R35 | Nick Costa rush for 9 yards to the RPI44, 1ST DOWN RPI (Genaro Scampone;Travis Ladd). |
| R | 1-10 | R44 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Pat McCarthy for 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Kody Parkhurst). |
| R | 2-4 | R50 | Nick Costa rush to the 50 yardline, fumble forced by Kevin Hennion, fumble by Nick Costa recovered by RPI Austin Caswell at 50 yardline. |
| R | 3-4 | R50 | Mike Hermann rush for 7 yards to the UTICA43, 1ST DOWN RPI (Marquez Mosely). |
| R | 1-10 | U43 | Matt Wood rush for 1 yard to the UTICA42 (Jerrod Clowes). |
| R | 2-9 | U42 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Austin Caswell for 8 yards to the UTICA34 (Jonathan White). |
| R | 3-1 | U34 | Matt Wood rush for 4 yards to the UTICA30, 1ST DOWN RPI (Travis Ladd;Genaro Scampone). |
| R | 1-10 | U30 | Pat McCarthy rush for 3 yards to the UTICA27 (Kevin Hennion). |
| R | 2-7 | U27 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Austin Caswell for 27 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN RPI, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:00. |
| | | Peter Nilson kick attempt good. |
| | | RPI 21, Utica College 21 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 73 yards, TOP 04:12 |
| | | Peter Nilson kickoff 40 yards to the UTICA25, Zachary Jensen return 12 yards to the UTICA37 (Will Gottschalk). |
| U | 1-10 | U37 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 10:50 (2nd). |
| U | 1-10 | U37 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Matt Dunn for 9 yards to the UTICA46 (Colin King). |
| U | 2-1 | U46 | Zachary Jones rush for 1 yard to the UTICA47, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Colin King). |
| U | 1-10 | U47 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Matt Dunn for 17 yards to the RPI36, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Justin Hasselku;Jeff McCormick). |
| U | 1-10 | R36 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 4 yards to the RPI32 (Ray Pasco). |
| U | 2-6 | R32 | Timeout RPI, clock 08:42. |
| U | 2-6 | R32 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 16 yards to the RPI16, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Frame). |
| U | 1-10 | R16 | UTICA ball on RPI16. |
| U | 1-10 | R16 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by Colin King at the RPI13, Colin King return 3 yards to the RPI16 (Jake Scott). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 47 yards, TOP 03:05 |
| R | 1-10 | R16 | RPI drive start at 07:45 (2nd). |
| R | 1-10 | R16 | TJ Strunk rush for loss of 2 yards to the RPI14 (Travis Ladd). |
| R | 2-12 | R14 | Mike Hermann pass complete to TJ Strunk for loss of 4 yards to the RPI10 (Kevin Hennion). |
| R | 3-16 | R10 | Mike Hermann pass incomplete to Steven Burpoe. |
| R | 4-16 | R10 | Mike Grubbs punt 15 yards to the RPI25, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| U | 1-10 | R25 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 06:37 (2nd). |
| U | 1-10 | R25 | Jake Scott rush for 4 yards to the RPI21 (Cody Hinrichs). |
| U | 2-6 | R21 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 16 yards to the RPI5, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Frame;Matthew Day). |
| U | 1-G | R05 | Jake Scott rush for 4 yards to the RPI1 (Cody Hinrichs;Matthew Day). |
| U | 2-G | R01 | Jake Scott rush for 1 yard to the RPI0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:44. |
| | | TJ Losowski kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica College 28, RPI 21 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 49 yards to the RPI16, Matt Wood return 20 yards to the RPI36 (Omari Byfield;Sean Fontanez). |
| R | 1-10 | R36 | RPI drive start at 04:39 (2nd). |
| R | 1-10 | R36 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Austin Caswell for 2 yards to the RPI38 (Tracy Branch). |
| R | 2-8 | R38 | Mike Hermann pass incomplete to Pat McCarthy (Kody Parkhurst). |
| R | 3-8 | R38 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Austin Caswell for 14 yards to the UTICA48, 1ST DOWN RPI (Kevin Hennion). |
| R | 1-10 | U48 | Pat McCarthy rush for 5 yards to the UTICA43 (Kevin Hennion). |
| R | 2-5 | U43 | Nick Costa rush for 6 yards to the UTICA37, 1ST DOWN RPI (Cody Adams). |
| R | 1-10 | U37 | TJ Strunk rush for 5 yards to the UTICA32 (T. Cunningham;James Brain). |
| R | 2-5 | U32 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Ray Davis for 8 yards to the UTICA24, 1ST DOWN RPI (Jonathan White). |
| R | 1-10 | U24 | Mike Hermann pass incomplete. |
| R | 2-10 | U24 | Mike Hermann pass complete to Pat McCarthy for 5 yards to the UTICA19 (Jonathan White;Genaro Scampone). |
| R | 3-5 | U19 | Mike Hermann rush for 2 yards to the UTICA17 (Kevin Hennion;T. Cunningham). |
| R | 4-3 | U17 | Timeout RPI, clock 00:26. |
| R | 4-3 | U17 | Peter Nilson field goal attempt from 34 MISSED - wide left, spot at UTICA20, clock 00:22. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 47 yards, TOP 04:17 |
| U | 1-10 | U20 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA19. |
| U | 2-11 | U19 | End of 1st half, clock 00:00. |